Time for the third, and lengthiest, installment yet concerning the Yankees in 2008: The infield. We'll go from left, and reigning American League MVP Alex Rodriguez, to the big question mark known as first base.
Oh, and one quick aside-- looks like the New York Times has caught onto Brett Gardner fever. Again, the only thing missing from his game (though its a BIG thing) is power.
Here's the link: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03/24/sports/baseball/24yankees.html?_r=1&ref=sports&oref=slogin
* * *
Infielders:
Alex Rodriguez (3B) -- 10 years, $275 million, $30 million in potential bonuses. I think its incredibly funny that last Sunday's Miguel Cabrera signing for 8 years and $153 million was hyped to the max, while the richest contract ever signed in baseball history barely got the back pages in New York. But, I guess if one polarizing figure can transcend a $300 million price tag, its "Alexander the Great."
There's little that I can add for background, because if you're reading this, chances are you know all the details: Big fanfare coming to the Yankees in 2004. Two MVP's in four years, while the Red Sox have two titles in four years. Atrocious clutch hitting in the playoffs (only one extra-base hit in over 60 AB since Game 4 of the 2004 ALCS). The "Ha!" game in Toronto, in the midst of a whirlwind extramarital affair. Love/hate relationship with Derek Jeter. Opting out of his contract during the World Series clincher last season, then apologies and coming back hat in hand to the Steinbrenners to stay in pinstripes. The possible sacking of uber-agent Scott Boras. Big-time man crush on Yankees hitting coach Kevin Long.
The Yankees are not Derek Jeter's team anymore (Mike Lupica in fact said the very same in his New York Daily News column yesterday: http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/baseball/yankees/2008/03/23/2008-03-23_yankees_in_arod_we_trust.html)
Good, bad, but never indifferent, the Yankee Universe revolves around (un)lucky number 13-- and the Yankees just offered at least 275 million reasons as to why.
As a defender, A-Rod got back to his normal self after a very poor 2006 (24 errors, tying a career high) at the hot corner-- losing bulk in the 2006-07 off-season and thereby increasing his athleticism and stamina, he made only 13 last season. He still has one of the best infield arms in baseball-- with a quick release, balls look like laser beams flying from his hand to first base on ground outs. However, its still a bit disconcerting that Rodriguez has kept the odd sidearm motion that he, without rhyme or reason, adapted to two years ago when throwing the ball. Many of his throws are simply all arm and no drive from the lower body. By not coming over the top like he used to, A-Rod has occasional balance issues that don't allow him to set his feet properly and square up in the direction he throws, leading to balls curving right and away from first basemen, and sometimes dangerously close to runners trying to reach. It seems that a collision and injury, if A-Rod doesn't change his style, is that more likely to happen for a Jason Giambi or Shelley Duncan when trying to stretch for errant throws.
Back to the relatively positive, A-Rod moves incredibly well to his right and steals a lot of line drive doubles inside the foul lines away from hitters. His range is still a solid tick above average for a third baseman, but his Gold Glove days are probably over because of the moderate amount of errors each year and because too many singles pass by him in the third base/shortstop gap when lunging towards his left. He probably couldn't play anything above a serviceable shortstop anymore, either-- though Derek Jeter, if healthy, will occupy that spot for the next three or four years, and possibly beyond. Simply put, he's an everyday, more-than-adequate presence (averaging 155 games at 3B) in the field for the Yankees.
I'm always torn about a line-up being constructed around A-Rod, which I know will seem foolish, and borderline blasphemous, to most Yankee fans. However, my eyes do not lie with what I've seen now watching the guy everyday for four seasons, so here's the real article about A-Rod: its downhill from here. I was there watching when he hit walk-off homers against Chris Ray and Joe Borowski in April. I saw the 9th inning Papel-bomb he launched into the Red Sox bullpen at Fenway in June off the Boston closer, with the Yankees struggling just to get back to .500, let alone the playoff hunt. I saw the three homers hit hit during that tide-turning Labor Day series against Seattle at Yankee Stadium, including the gargantuan blast off of Horatio Ramirez into the middle of the left-field upper deck, a place where I've only seen one other hitter reach, and barely (Gary Sheffield off of Alan Embree in 2005). After all that in 2007-- 54 homers, 156 RBIs, 143 runs scored-- he's still not the guy I want up with the game on the line.
The big thing A-Rod did to have such an amazing season was, as I mentioned earlier, shedding weight to make his bat quicker through the zone. A right-handed hitter in a ballpark and team with a lineage of catering to lefty mashers, the reason he bulked up prior was to have the type of power to hit homers out to cavernous left-center, and thus, all fields in Yankee Stadium. The side effect was that A-Rod just simply couldn't get around on a plus-velocity fastball anymore, and Detroit's Justin Verlander, Jeremy Bonderman, and Joel Zumaya continually blew it by his "slider-speed bat" in the 2006 ALDS. Leaner meant meaner in 2007, as A-Rod had far better success against the opposing teams' scouting report of pitching him inside with hard stuff-- instead of losing power, A-Rod truly enhanced it by crafting his body into a lither build, exploding on anything out and over the plate into the right-centerfield bleachers, and getting around on inside fastballs and launching doubles and homers to left. In fact, its that ability to take the ball the other way, with amazing hand and wrist strength, for homers over the 385-foot wall in right-center that makes A-Rod a one-of-a-kind hitter. Its where he hits 'em when he's at his best, and I've never seen a player, on this any other team, who does that consistently other than A-Rod. None.
And besides Manny Ramirez, there's nobody in baseball that can hammer off-speed stuff, particularly sliders, like A-Rod. If I were an opposing manager, I'd tell my pitchers to never throw a strike to A-Rod unless its bound to blow past him due to velocity. To beat him consistently with anything other than a plus-fastball, a pitcher will need to have mid-90's power sinker (think Fausto Carmona or even Yankee teammate Chien-Ming Wang) that's too heavy to lift, or a devastating splitter (think Curt Schilling, though you might not ever consider him anymore with injuries and age rendering him all but retired). Thus, you'll find that A-Rod will have the other-worldly regular season stats, hitting a never-ending slew of mediocre starters on bad teams who max out at 88-92 MPH and feasting on the soft underbelly that is middle relief in the American League, and will struggle mightily against the aces and set-up men/closers of playoff teams as the weather turns colder and velocity of heaters closes in on triple digits.
That said, for all the reshaping and retooling with Kevin Long, A-Rod still strikes out too much. As many times as he'll break open a first inning with Johnny Damon, Jeter, and Bobby Abreu on base, he'll foul things up just as much with not putting the ball in play. Trust me, you can do far, far worse than A-Rod there in the clean-up spot-- but if the Yankees had Albert Pujols in that spot, I'd have no doubt they'd finally reach that elusive 1,000 runs scored as a team milestone. Though, I'm sure, everyone would take Albert Pujols in their lineup. A-Rod still runs very well and very smart, and steals bases at a very high success rate (24 out of 28 in 2007).
Statistics vs. clutch play will remain the divide between Yankee fans-- will ten more years of 40 homer, 100 RBI seasons, 20 steals, All-Star starts, and an eventual passing of Babe Ruth, Hank Aaron, and Barry Bonds, be enough without eventual playoff success? He's in his prime now-- if its going to be done with him as the legitimate focal point as the Yankees' best player, its got to be done within the next two or three years. Maybe I'm wrong-- I just don't see A-Rod being any better than he was last season, and the Yankees still didn't get past the first round of the playoffs. He says all the right things to the press-- he wants a title more than any other accolade, and wants to do it in New York, wearing a Yankee uniform, finishing out his career. Still, he's a mentally soft player that, if you look at the bottom line between winning and losing championships, hasn't been worth the distraction, nor the price of admission. All you can hope for as a fan is redemption sometime down the road. Hope, not trust.
Derek Jeter (SS) -- Its hard to come down on the captain of a successful baseball team and a guy who has won 4 World Series titles-- yet Jeter enters this year in limbo. In name, he's the leader of the team-- but is he really the focal point of the Yankees anymore? Or even their THIRD-best player? A season removed from finishing second in the AL MVP award race, Jeter had a slight regression in most offensive categories in 2007, and for the first time in his career, his ability to play shortstop has been called into question by now-infamous sabermetrician Bill James, whose Baseball Handbook tracks the ranges of infielders through statistical analysis. Above all, his postseason was incredibly poor (.176, 4 K, and 3 GIDP in 17 at-at bats), and though a four game sample is hardly indicative of the talent of a ballplayer, remember this is Derek Jeter-- Mr. Clutch, Mr. Playoffs. That reputation will never go away fully, yet you wonder how much of the invincible aura of Jeter diminishes as the Yankees move further and further from 2000 and their last championship.
As I mentioned, Bill James categorizes Jeter's 2007 season as the worst of all regular major league shortstops, with his range being limited to his left (glove) side to the point that any hard hit ball up the middle will get past Jeter if he isn't within a body length of it, and his 18 errors were his most since his career high of 24 in 2000. Other baseball people still say that Jeter plays the position quite well-- he has a strong arm and makes that classic jumping throw while his momentum is carrying him the other way into the outfield (and if you've ever seen a commercial for the MLB playoffs, or have watched the playoffs, or hell, if you've ever watched the Yankees for more than a few games at a time, you can envision that exact play in your mind) with seemingly pinpoint control. Jeter's athleticism also allows him to turn a pretty double play, and his flair for the heads-up, hustle play (think the relay throw in the 2001 ALDS vs. Oakland and the dive into the stands in 2004 vs. Boston) are intangibles that cannot be charted and broken down. Is he a bit overrated because of the flashy play and his exposure by playing in New York? Certainly. Did he deserve the three Gold Gloves he won from 2004-2006 when he didn't even have a .980 fielding percentage in any of those years? Probably not. But he's done enough over the course of his career to justify playing him everyday at shortstop in 2008, and he's still in his prime.
... And, like most of the Yankee All-Stars, Jeter makes his pay by being a premier offensive player. Year in and year out, you expect 200 hits and a batting average well above .300, coupled with 110 runs and an on-base percentage close to .400, which makes him a force out of the two-hole. Jeter is unique because his approach at the plate is to almost "dive" into a pitch with his body, leading to outstanding plate coverage with his swing. Pitchers will try to counteract Jeter's method by burying fastballs up and in around his hands, but with his level, inside-out swing, Jeter explodes on the ball by getting great rotation and torque from his upper body while planting firm his back leg, becoming a master at hitting singles the opposite way to right-center field. In fact, if Jeter sacrificed all power and decided to become an Ichiro-style slap hitter, he could probably challenge DiMaggio's 56-game hit streak, because he could have two singles every game if he wanted. His consistency is unmatched amongst his Yankee teammates, who often have gone into prolonged slumps in efforts to meet expectation-- every month in 2007, Jeter hit over .300, a remarkable feat. His power in and of itself is slightly below-average with his approach because Jeter will never compromise his average and ability to hit into the opposite-field gap for doubles, so he rarely ever pulls the ball. If all lines up, he could hit 20 home runs again, but I wouldn't expect more than 15 in any season from this point onwards in his career. He's a very smart, above-average baserunner who used to be elite, but nowadays will occasionally get thrown out going from first to third and gets into a few too many rundowns. His speed is still good, and he's a year removed from his career-high of 34 steals in 2006-- though team philosophy has dictated whether or not Jeter makes the most of his running game. With Girardi's small-ball, he could have 30 again.
The Bombers could win it all in 2008, and with a typical Jeter postseason of heroics, he'll be Teflon forever-- and yes, I do think it would take one more title for that to happen. But if the rotten karma that's haunted the Yankees since the outset of this decade persists, I don't think Jeter could keep playing the role of the calm, omniscient figure and have his teammates regard him as a leader with a pulse. He plays with fire and passion, and is a leader by example to be sure-- but there's an aloofness that comes off in his interviews and dealings with the media that makes you think he's frustrated and incapable of relating to his teammates, who are thirsty to have rings like he does. I could be wrong, and he could be a fiery, approachable guy that his teammates adore behind the scenes... but I'm of the mindset of "what-you-see-is-what-you-get" when it comes to Jeter.
Robinson Cano (2B) -- Ladies and gentlemen, meet the reason you should be excited about Yankee baseball going forward. Not A-Rod, not Jeter, and not even Hughes, Chamberlain, and Kennedy (though you should be excited about all those guys in the years to come)-- its Robbie Cano, doncha know (to steal from John Sterling once more)...
Fresh from signing over his remaining controlled years (and possible fortune made through salary arbitration) for a nice little payday ($30 million over the next four seasons), Cano is the Yankees best player age 25 or younger, and there are a handful of potentially elite players to choose from-- not bad for a guy that was being shopped all over the place for pitching help in 2004 and rejected by several scouts from other clubs, particularly Arizona when initially exploring the eventually-consummated Randy Johnson trade (instead of Cano as the centerpiece of the deal, the Diamondbacks got pitcher Javier Vazquez). A career .314 hitter in three seasons in New York with developing power, Cano is being predicted by many to be the best offensive second baseman in the majors over the course of the next five years and the Yankees' eventual successor to Bobby Abreu, occupying the all-important third spot in the high-octane Yankee lineup. He's tearing up Spring Training to the tune of a .467 average, mixing in doubles and a couple of long, majestic homers and making hitting look easy-- its hard not to be incredibly optimistic about Cano being the silent catalyst of what could be a legendary Yankee offense in 2008.
What will surprise most people who aren't familiar with Cano is that he could be a Gold Glove-quality second baseman. He was brought up in the system slowly and initially was a big-time liability as an infielder, making a ton of mental errors. Even in 2005 and his rookie campaign, he would occasionally make the errant, easy throw and cost the Yankees a big inning or two-- now heading into 2008, he's put together a real solid game, thanks in large part to an incredible work ethic and the mentoring of now-departed third base coach Larry Bowa, who worked extensively with Cano as his pet project in 2006 and 2007. First, he's got a well-above average arm for a second baseman-- one that could translate well at shortstop or even third base-- but with two Hall-of-Famers occupying the left side of the Yankee infield in A-Rod and Jeter, Cano is more or less planted at 2B. His range is above-average, covering a lot of ground to both sides, and he makes the diving play to his left as well as anyone in baseball today. Perhaps the best quality Cano has as a fielder, though, is a fearless nature in turning the double play-- he doesn't shy from barreling baserunners coming in hard to second base and completes his throws knowing that there's a good chance he'll be upended or spiked, and possibly injured. That also includes making tags on stolen base attempts, as he's always in good position and makes quick, fluid tags. All the little intangibles that make a second baseman great Cano exhibits, and has become a wonderful defensive presence. He's incredibly fun to watch.
As a hitter, there's merit to the claims from baseball experts that Robinson Cano could win a batting title or two. With an open stance, he rocks in a rhythmic pattern in the batter's box before zeroing on the ball, giving him a good view of pitches coming out of the hands of righties and lefties alike. His sweet, fluid stroke relies on good timing, which leads to streakiness as a hitter, which in turn makes such a high average year in and year out incredibly impressive. After hitting .342 in 2006, Cano started slow in the first half of 2007 (.274, with a mere 6 home runs) before getting back to that elite echelon of contact hitters in the second half (.343 and 13 homers). With Cano still a few years away from his prime, its truly scary to envision what he might become if he keeps progressing. Cano has average speed and runs the bases just fine, but probably will never steal more than 10 bases in a season because of his role in the lineup and overall lack of basestealing skill.
If there's a weakness to Cano's hitting, its the fact that his pitch selection at the plate still needs significant improvement-- though its encouraging to see that he more than doubled his walk total in 2007 (39, to the 18 he had in 2006) from the year before. If he walks 55-60 times this year, it'll make him that much more dangerous, because it'll also mean that he'd be cutting down on strikeouts as well (his 85 K in 617 AB, however, is a respectable number). As aforementioned, expect his power to take a jump this year, as now he's really coming into his own-- and as I've said with many players so far, a lefty hitter who drops the bat head on the ball with authority will reap the benefits of the short porch in right field. I think he could rival A-Rod as the offensive force of the Yankees this year-- .330 (good for a run at the batting title), 25-30 HR, his first 100 RBI season, and 45 2B. If he does that, The Yankees will probably let Abreu go and try to get a Mark Teixeira to come in and be the 5-hitter in 2009, leading to a Cano/A-Rod/Teixeira heart of the order, behind Johnny Damon and Jeter. Unreal, if it ever happens-- and it certainly could, as Teixeira was a Yankee, particularly a Don Mattingly, fan growing up.
Jason Giambi (1B) -- The "Giambino" reported to Spring Training this year perhaps in the best shape he's been (well, at least while not aided by performance-enhancing drugs) while as a Yankee, and its probably little surprise he's done so for a few obvious reasons:
1) Its a contract year for the 37-year-old slugger, and he's auditioning for perhaps one last payday.
2) He's taking preventative measures by getting in peak shape to avoid the injury bug which has plagued him off and on during his Yankee days.
and:
3) With younger, hungry guys like Shelley Duncan and Wilson Betemit vying for playing time under a new manager who preaches fitness and physical preparation, Giambi basically had no choice without the backing of Joe Torre, which he had for the past six seasons-- it was either shape up or ship out.
Giambi hasn't lived up to the seven-year, $120 million the Yankees paid him to become the cog that would extend the 1996-2001 Yankee dynasty. Taking away the best player on their then-closest rival, the Oakland A's, the theory was that the Yankees had let Tino Martinez go at the tail end of his usefulness and had gotten a year-in, year-out MVP candidate. Martinez was eventually back, insurance for Giambi's mysterious "tapeworm" that partly sabotaged an ill-fated 2004 season and cut into the first two months of 2005. He's had ups (AL Comeback Player of the Year in 2005, playing in the World Series after hitting two homers off Pedro Martinez in Game 7 of the 2003 ALCS), downs (steroids, "tapeworms," and most recently, a broken foot which forced him to miss half of last season), and yet he's still respected and revered by teammates and remains one of baseball's more affable, friendly players. He's an anomaly in baseball-- an honest, forthright, and accountable guy who did a dishonest thing and lost major creditability. A World Series title has eluded his time in New York, which seemed unfathomable considering the promise he brought to the Bronx in what seems like a lifetime ago.
Defensively, Giambi's improved shape has allowed him slight improvements on his limited range. I always believed that the criticism about Giambi being an absolute statue at first base was a bit harsh and overstated. He actually has a two strengths, the most noticable being that he is quite adept at scooping balls that are thrown almost at his feet on errant throws-- if its close, Giambi's a vacuum, catching anything thrown his way, and has good baseball sense when playing the position, knowing when he needs to make a swipe tag if throws are REALLY offline. The second positive to his game is that he genuinely hustles and will surprise you at times with making athletic plays (this Spring in a game against the Twins, I remember vividly how Giambi leapt up as high as his linebacker body and snagged a screaming line drive to take away a potential big inning for Minnesota). That said, he has always been uncomfortable, and therefore erratic at making throws to second when turning 3-6-3 double plays, and his lack of foot speed makes it almost impossible for Giambi to field bunts down the first base line, often leading to pitchers having to chase down balls they probably shouldn't have to. At this stage in his career, Giambi has become an max-effort player in trying to get to ground balls, trying justify not being a full-time DH. He has stated that, for some inexplicable reason, he feels more comfortable hitting when he plays in the field as well. While I don't ascribe much to that theory (see: David Ortiz), its probably best not to mess with Giambi's mojo if he's healthy, because even with poor defense, he's not as bad as he's often made out to be and will relieve the problem of finding playing time for both Johnny Damon and Hideki Matsui.
It seems like its always a huge surprise within the last three or four years when Giambi puts up good numbers, but for as enigmatic as his injury/illness history has been, when healthy, he's still an All-Star-caliber force. Perhaps only Bobby Abreu can match the plate discipline and presence of Giambi, who still may have the best batter's eye in all of baseball with an incredible knowledge and understanding of the strike zone. He's past his prime, but plate discipline is almost like an inherent skill that hardly diminishes-- if you have it, you'll always have it, and when you don't, hitting will always be inconsistent, and dependent on the skill of the opposing pitcher (i.e. in this day in age, when pitchers have binders upon binders filled with statistics, along with video tape, they're MUCH smarter and often have the advantage). Experience alone will allow Giambi to have an OBP close to .400 if not above-- his career number is .411, which includes the bizarre 2004 season and last year, both cut short by injuries-- and he could walk 100 times again, which makes him such a valuable weapon if he is slotted down in the sixth or seventh in the lineup. Its amazing that those in the everyday lineup, 1-to-9, could have a shot at 100 RBI if they remain healthy (though the "Melk Man" would be a BIG stretch) -- and the key to that will be Jeter, Abreu, and Giambi getting on base over 40% of the time. Power-wise, Giambi is a dead-pull hitter that still can take mistakes middle-in and park them deep into the confines of any ballpark-- reports are Giambi and hitting coach Kevin Long are working on Giambi going the other way, which will up his doubles and batting average, but I've also heard those claims before, and defenses will no doubt still use the "Giambi shift" (which shows you how much of a reputation he has for pulling the ball) to neutralize any balls hit below their heads. Giambi continues to regress gradually in his ability to catch up with a high fastball, so pitchers will keep trying to pitch him up and away and if they don't give in, they'll be met with one of two fates-- either falling behind in the count and walking Giambi or retiring him on either weak contact or a swinging strikeout.
The barrel-chested Giambi is often death on the bases, often looking like comical while hustling from first-to-third (think Fred Flintstone twinkle-toeing around a baseball diamond), and is held to singles on balls that would often be doubles for runners with merely average speed. So again, the question will be how much Giambi's body transformation will help him in the speed department. My guess would be not too much, so expect Giambi to be pinch-ran for late in games.
Expect him to surprise you and be more-or-less healthy through the whole season (If he plays 140 games at a high level, it'd be the first time since 2003), but don't be surprised by 30 HR, .275 AVG, .400 OBP, 100 RBI, 100 BB-- he can do just that if you believe in the power of a contract year. I'd imagine he'll do everything in his power to force Joe Girardi to keep Duncan, Betemit, and Morgan Ensberg away from first and instead towards other positions. History's not on my side, but I just have a hunch.
Wilson Betemit (1B, 2B, SS, and 3B) -- In terms of talent, the Yankees basically stole Betemit from the Los Angeles Dodgers last year at the trade deadline for journeyman reliever Scott Proctor, and in his first at-bat in pinstripes against All-Star hurler Jon Garland-- then of the White Sox-- Betemit launched a long home run just shy of the blacked-out bleachers in center field. It was essentially his lone highlight in New York, as he struggled with irregular playing time to find a rhythm at the plate, hitting a mere .226 in 84 AB. Yet he's only 26 and just entering his prime, has big-time power potential and already-existing numbers (if you combine his at-bats in 2006 and 2007 and create essentially one full year, you get this line: 32 HR, 35 2B, and 103 RBI), and the Yankees--whether you believe them or not-- said they were fully prepared to have Betemit start at third base if Alex Rodriguez had left through free agency. That says a lot about how the franchise feels about Betemit. For now, he'll be relied upon to serve as a super-utility infielder who can play at any position, though his strength is playing on the left side (3B or SS). He could start for several clubs right now, and might serve as trade bait for a third season in a row if the Yankees find themselves in need of pitching help at the end of July.
Playing four different positions, and all four at least adequately, creates irreplaceable value for the Yankees, who will probably want to carry 12 pitchers on their 25-man roster as they begin to break in a young crop of starters and a questionable bunch of middle relievers. Shortening their bench could allow Betemit to piece together a 350 AB season, which also makes him a more valuable hitter. Betemit made only 7 errors last year while bouncing all around the diamond, and he's solid-average all across the board. He's got a fairly strong arm-- though I'd have to see more than the limited action I've seen thus far to rate it above-average. If you don't believe in Giambi staying healthy, odds are he'll spend most of his time at 1B, Betemit's newest and least-comfortable position-- something to keep an eye on.
The switch-hitting of Betemit, on the surface, seems like another big-time bonus for a part-time player, but he probably should stick with the left side of the plate, especially playing in Yankee Stadium. From the right, he's simply a non-factor and probably couldn't even be called a big league talent. Here are the career splits:
Left-Handed: .263 AVG, .347 OBP, .464 SLG, 31 HR, 101 RBI, 39 2B
Right-Handed: .232 AVG, .281 OBP, .353 SLG, 5 HR, 25 RBI, 8 2B
The real problem, left or right, though, is that Betemit strikes out at a higher rate than any other Yankee-- 258 K in 909 career AB averages out to be 1 K per 3.5 AB, and that rate became even worse in a half-season playing for New York (33 K in 84 AB, or 1 K per 2.5 AB). His swing is long and Betemit still has problems with chasing pitches out of the zone, like young hitters tend to do (which goes to show what makes Robinson Cano, a player of similar service time and age, such a special player-- in 1261 career at-bats, Cano has struck out 207 times, or 1 K per 7.8 AB). Still, like Shelley Duncan from the opposite side, he's a hitter than could scare a RHP late in games with his ability to slam homers in pinch-hit situations. When he starts, he be placed in the eighth spot in the lineup. Its hard to accurately predict what he could contribute, but double-digit homers and a fair share of doubles are safe bets.
Morgan Ensberg (1B and 3B) -- I'm a little confused as to why Morgan Ensberg was added to the 40-Man roster earlier this week, though he certainly offered the best pedigree of all the non-roster invitees in camp this Spring Training. A former college standout at USC and an All-Star in 2005, Ensberg battled inconsistency and injury in 2006 and 2007, and was let go by the Houston Astros before being signed by the San Diego Padres for their pennant chase. There, he was underwhelming, too-- hitting just .224, though he did have 4 homers in just 58 AB.
Ensberg's stats are baffling. 2005 seemed to be a fluky arrangement of spikes (26 more homers than 2004, 49 more BB, and 73 more Ks in only 100 more AB), and then he walked 101 times in 2006 and had only 91 hits-- the only other player to do that was Barry Bonds. You just simply do not know what to expect, so my feeling is that the Yankees felt that even a .234 average this spring was not indicative of what they feel they'll get from him during the regular season. Though Chris Woodward, Cody Ransom, Jason Lane, and perhaps even Greg Porter had just as good, if not better numbers in March, none offer the promise of a player with over 100 career home runs. He's a high-risk, high-reward talent that will round out the roster and play mostly first base.
Defensively, Ensberg is nothing to write home about and makes his fair share of errors (a career fielding percentage of .955 is a shade below average). His arm is fine, but not in the league of an A-Rod or even Betemit. He's played only one career game at first base, but from his experience at playing third-- the harder, more athletic postion-- Ensberg should be a quick study and better defensively than Giambi or Shelley Duncan.
As a hitter, the Yankees hope that Ensberg can give them some right-handed pop in a very lefty-heavy lineup. Coming from a homer haven in Houston to Yankee Stadium and "Death Valley," Ensberg will be lucky to hit 10 home runs this season if you combine lack of plate appearances, physical degeneration, and degree of difficulty. He could have actually had a similar revival to Mike Lowell in Boston had he made the Red Sox, as I can see Ensberg hitting a lot of doubles off the Green Monster in Fenway Park. I envision that Girardi might find Ensberg some playing time when the Yankees visit the Sox-- just a feeling. To be truly effective, however, Ensberg will have to show the ability to get on-base at the level of 2005-06, where his OBP was close to .400. He doesn't hit for a high average, so if he can do that, he'll fit in nicely with the team concept of taking pitches and "keeping the line moving." To me, however, he seems like a player that doesn't really fit in with the mentality that Girardi is trying to implement-- speed, hit-and-run, and defense. We'll see what happens.
Alberto Gonzalez (SS) -- No, not the failed Attorney General, but the slick-fielding prospect the Yankees feel could be a great defensive replacement late in games after a bit more seasoning in the minors. On the 40-man roster, Gonzalez will most likely not be seen at the big-league level until September when the rosters expand. Playing last year at AA Trenton, Gonzalez had a fast start, hitting .330 in 28 games and earning a promotion to AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. There, he regressed against superior talent, dropping to .247-- though he did have 11 of his 12 steals on the year in AAA. In camp this year, Gonzalez has hit .208. He was one of the four players dealt to the Yankees in the Randy Johnson trade during the 2006-07 offseason, and is highly thought of in the farm system.
Fielding being a strength, Gonzalez has well-above average range and an average arm which can develop as he gets older. With the Yankees in September, though, he looked a little hesitant and overwhelmed in what was essentially a pressure-free environment after the Yankees clinched halfway through September, which led to sloppy play-- he only had one error, but I was lucky enough to have seen most of his time in the field and that's the impression I was left with. Another year at AAA will probably perfect his skills, but all scouting reports say that he could be the Yankees' best defensive infielder right now.
Gonzalez only had one hit in his 14 AB in September, and at this point, he's not ready to contribute offensively with any consistency for the Yankees. If all goes right, Gonzalez could be a .250 hitter in the majors with below-average power and above-average speed, though he needs to hone his craft at swiping bases (12 SB last season at three levels, but 7 CS as well, which is too many). If he can increase his average to somewhere around .270 or .280 at Scranton/Wilkes-Barre this year, he may warrant consideration to be Jeter's backup in 2009, provided Betemit could be traded or released by that time.
Juan Miranda (1B) -- The Yankees invested $2 million in the 24-year-old Cuban product in December of 2006 with visions of home run after home run leaping from his left-handed bat. Miranda remains on the 40-man roster, but will begin the season at AA Trenton, where he was part of last year's Eastern League championship squad. If all goes according to plan and Miranda develops well as a hitter, he could compete for a job next year, but a lot can, and will, happen between now and then that might block him from ever starting regularly in the Bronx.
Miranda has below-average range at first and with a wide, bulky body, may not be athletic enough to play first base on an everyday basis. He's still learning the nuances of the game, and will be average for a handful of years in the league in the best of scenarios. However...
...The Yankees love his bat, and in his first season of organized ball at two levels in the U.S. and seeing all-new pitching, he had 16 HR, 96 RBI, and 34 2B in 446 at-bats, which was quite impressive and just a start to what the Yankees feel could be 30-homer power. Interestingly, despite Miranda being described as a below-average runner, he had five triples, which probably means that he's got a good sense of knowing when to take the extra base. He didn't really do anything remarkable this Spring, but he could be someone to watch out for if he gets off to a hot start in the minors and the Yankees are dealing with injuries.